Nobody Writes Alone
An editor can reshape a manuscript, and a ghostwriter can draft a book published under someone else's name. Computer-assisted writing adds another kind of help. The examples below show different arrangements; I would not treat them as interchangeable.
I want to answer by distinguishing the work involved. The publishing examples come first, then the account of my own book. None of the earlier arrangements settles what a reader should accept from me.
The publishing record runs from heavy editing to wholesale production, and I want to walk it slowly. On Maxwell Perkins' later account, the manuscript Thomas Wolfe brought Scribner's ran to about half a million words; Look Homeward, Angel came out in 1929 after work on reducing it had begun on Wolfe's return from Europe, and that account documents editorial work on a manuscript Wolfe had already written. [1] That is one kind of help. Behind the name Carolyn Keene, from 1930, Mildred Wirt Benson turned the Stratemeyer Syndicate's outlines into Nancy Drew books, 23 of the first 30 of them, and the University of Iowa's archive also describes flat-fee sales of her work and royalty rights. [2] That is another kind, a different division of labour from editing an existing manuscript.
Then there is John F. Kennedy's Profiles in Courage, winner of the 1957 Pulitzer Prize for history, where the allocation of credit was contested. When Ted Sorensen died, his Washington Post obituary reported his acknowledgement that he had written a first draft of most chapters, and it also recorded his affidavit maintaining that Kennedy was the author. [3] I cannot settle that contest from here, and I do not need to. Kevin Nance, writing in 2013, laid out James Patterson's process as it then ran: detailed outlines, drafts by co-writers, revisions by Patterson, the last word in any disagreement staying with Patterson. His report gives collaborator Mark Sullivan's own words on the point ("He's the boss, and I have no problem with that"), and it notes exceptions in how the outlines were developed, so I read it as an account of particular working relationships rather than a rule for every book carrying Patterson's name. [4] For Prince Harry's Spare the collaborator was J.R. Moehringer, who had also worked on Andre Agassi's Open and Phil Knight's Shoe Dog. A $1 million fee for that book was reported by the BBC, but the BBC was attributing the figure to Page Six, not to any disclosed contract. [5]
Each of these arrangements puts drafting, editing and final control in different hands. They do not establish that the division of labour stayed the same for a century, or that readers always cared about one question. Before judging the work, I would want the arrangement described.
So what changes when a program produces the text?
The Policeman's Beard Is Half Constructed was published in 1984; its catalogue credits Racter, a program written by William Chamberlain and Thomas Etter. [6] In September 2015, Satoshi Sato's team submitted two computer-generated stories to the third Hoshi Shinichi Award. His 2016 paper describes a system using a human-prepared story grammar and text fragments. It says eleven of 2,561 entries used computer help and that one of four publicly released entries passed the first screening round; it does not identify that entry in the passage. [7, pp31-32] Ross Goodwin's 1 the Road was published in 2018. The publisher describes a Cadillac fitted with sensors feeding a writing system, which printed text during a New York to New Orleans journey. Publication year does not by itself date the drive. [8] K Allado-McDowell's account of Pharmako-AI describes a fortnight of exchanges with GPT-3 during the first pandemic summer, and calls it the first book co-created with that model. That priority claim is the author's. [9] TIME reported in December 2022 that Ammaar Reshi made Alice and Sparkle using ChatGPT and Midjourney over a weekend, provoking objections about AI-generated art. [10] In 2023 Stephen Marche used several AI systems for Death of an Author. The New York Times reports his claim that 95 percent of its language was machine-generated. [11]
The books span several forms. No handful of examples can tell me how much of any bookshop is AI-assisted. What they show me is why to ask what a program did, what the human contributors did, and what was checked. The share of a text that is generated, on its own, says nothing about whether its argument is sound. Knowing the process points a reader at what to examine. The claims still need their evidence. None of the examples above verifies my book.
My own book
I am a civil engineer, and the book took five years to write. Its current Note on Method records 557 chapter bibliography entries and 586 numbered chapter endnotes. Those are entry counts, with repeated works across chapters, not 557 independent sources for every claim.
AI played a part in my research and writing process; however fluent a passage reads, it still has to be checked against the evidence it claims to represent.
I would judge the finished book by its reasoning and evidence, and I expect readers to question both; the sources are there to be followed, and a description of my process is not a substitute for doing that.
What Are We Missing? is planned for 13 February 2027. The book includes its chapter notes and bibliographies.

Zafar Alam is a civil engineer and Chartered Construction Manager with about 12 years on major projects. He is the author of What Are We Missing? How to Think More Clearly Before You Decide, planned for 13 February 2027.
Read next
A Lesson Is Not Learned Because We Wrote It DownWriting a lesson down is not learning it. What a handover, a closed action and a review change for the next project.The Cost of Analytical FailureThe Commission's account of the Macondo test and the decision to proceed.Notes
- Maxwell Perkins, "Answers to a Query on Thomas Wolfe", The Paris Review - Perkins's own account of Wolfe's ~500,000-word manuscript and the work of cutting it. https://www.theparisreview.org/letters-essays/672/answers-to-a-query-on-thomas-wolfe-maxwell-perkins
- University of Iowa Libraries, Iowa Women's Archives: Mildred Wirt Benson biography - the Stratemeyer Syndicate's outline system, flat fees, and her authorship of 23 of the first 30 Nancy Drew books as "Carolyn Keene". https://www.lib.uiowa.edu/iwa/mildred/biography/
- "JFK's speechwriter, confidant, counselor and a keeper of the Kennedy flame", The Washington Post, online 31 October 2010 (print edition 1 November 2010). Reports Sorensen's acknowledgment that he wrote a first draft of most chapters of Profiles in Courage. https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/10/31/AR2010103104887_pf.html
- "James Patterson: The way he writes, he might as well be printing money", The Washington Post, 17 January 2013 - the co-writing rules, the outlines, and who has the last word. https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/james-patterson-the-way-he-writes-he-might-as-well-be-printing-money/2013/01/17/cfbc8a62-5e9e-11e2-9940-6fc488f3fecd_story.html
- "Who is Harry's celebrated ghostwriter, JR Moehringer?", BBC News, January 2023 - Moehringer's role in Spare, the reported $1m fee, and his earlier books with Agassi and Knight. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-64217330
- Racter, The Policeman's Beard Is Half Constructed (1984) - scan and record at the Internet Archive. https://archive.org/details/policemansbeardi0000unse
- Satoshi Sato, "A Challenge to the Third Hoshi Shinichi Award", Proceedings of the INLG 2016 Workshop on Computational Creativity and Natural Language Generation, pp. 31-35. Nagoya University. The stories were submitted in September 2015. https://aclanthology.org/W16-5505.pdf
- Jean Boîte Éditions, publisher's page for 1 the Road by Ross Goodwin (2018) - the car, the sensors and the receipt-paper manuscript. https://www.jbe-books.com/products/1-the-road-by-an-artificial-neural
- K Allado-McDowell, author's page for Pharmako-AI - a fortnight's exchange with GPT-3, published as "the first book to be co-created with the emergent AI". https://www.kalladomcdowell.com/pharmakoai
- Nik Popli, "He Used AI to Publish a Children's Book in a Weekend. Artists Are Not Happy About It", TIME, 14 December 2022. https://time.com/6240569/ai-childrens-book-alice-and-sparkle-artists-unhappy/
- "A Human Wrote This Book Review. A.I. Wrote the Book.", The New York Times, 1 May 2023 - Marche's Death of an Author (Pushkin Industries, 2023) and his 95-per-cent figure. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/05/01/books/aidan-marchine-death-of-an-author.html